Predators affect their prey through consumptive and non-consumptive effects (NCEs). Regarding marine NCEs, predator chemical cues (e.g., exudates) can trigger various anti-predator responses in prey that can vary in magnitude according to the intensity of the perceived cues. Specimens of the mussel Perumytilus purpuratus were exposed to seawater that held different densities of the predatory snail Acanthina monodon as a proxy for predator cue intensity. The response of mussels was quantified in terms of valve gape size (VGS), clearance rate (CR), and oxygen consumption rate (OCR). The results showed that mussels reduced VGS, CR, and OCR as a function of the intensity of the predator exudates to which they were exposed. These results suggest that mussels are not only able to detect predators through their chemical exudates but can also detect the intensity of the predatory signal and thus respond physiologically (CR, OCR) and behaviorally (VGS) in accordance to the potential predation risk. These responses may have cascading effects at the community level, given that mussels are foundation species.