Colección SciELO Chile

Departamento Gestión de Conocimiento, Monitoreo y Prospección
Consultas o comentarios: productividad@anid.cl
Búsqueda Publicación
Búsqueda por Tema Título, Abstract y Keywords



Reporting guideline for overviews of reviews of healthcare interventions: development of the PRIOR statement
Indexado
WoS WOS:000849115800010
DOI 10.1136/BMJ-2022-070849
Año 2022
Tipo artículo de investigación

Citas Totales

Autores Afiliación Chile

Instituciones Chile

% Participación
Internacional

Autores
Afiliación Extranjera

Instituciones
Extranjeras


Abstract



OBJECTIVE To develop a reporting guideline for overviews of reviews of healthcare interventions.DEsIGN Development of the preferred reporting items for overviews of reviews (PRIOR) statement.PARTICIPANTs Core team (seven individuals) led day-to-day operations, and an expert advisory group (three individuals) provided methodological advice. A panel of 100 experts (authors, editors, readers including members of the public or patients) was invited to participate in a modified Delphi exercise. 11 expert panellists (chosen on the basis of expertise, and representing relevant stakeholder groups) were invited to take part in a virtual face-to-face meeting to reach agreement (a70%) on final checklist items. 21 authors of recently published overviews were invited to pilot test the checklist.SETTING International consensus. INTERVENTION Four stage process established by the EQUATOR Network for developing reporting guidelines in health research: project launch (establish a core team and expert advisory group, register intent), evidence reviews (systematic review of published overviews to describe reporting quality, scoping review of methodological guidance and author reported challenges related to undertaking overviews of reviews), modified Delphi exercise (two online Delphi surveys to reach agreement (a70%) on relevant reporting items followed by a virtual face-to-face meeting), and development of the reporting guideline.REsULTs From the evidence reviews, we drafted an initial list of 47 potentially relevant reporting items. An international group of 52 experts participated in the first Delphi survey (52% participation rate); agreement was reached for inclusion of 43 (91%) items. 44 experts (85% retention rate) completed the second Delphi survey, which included the four items lacking agreement from the first survey and five new items based on respondent comments. During the second round, agreement was not reached for the inclusion or exclusion of the nine remaining items. 19 individuals (6 core team and 3 expert advisory group members, and 10 expert panellists) attended the virtual face-to-face meeting. Among the nine items discussed, high agreement was reached for the inclusion of three and exclusion of six. Six authors participated in pilot testing, resulting in minor wording changes. The final checklist includes 27 main items (with 19 sub-items) across all stages of an overview of reviews.CONCLUsIONs PRIOR fills an important gap in reporting guidance for overviews of reviews of healthcare interventions. The checklist, along with rationale and example for each item, provides guidance for authors that will facilitate complete and transparent reporting. This will allow readers to assess the methods used in overviews of reviews of healthcare interventions and understand the trustworthiness and applicability of their findings.

Revista



Revista ISSN
0959-535X

Métricas Externas



PlumX Altmetric Dimensions

Muestra métricas de impacto externas asociadas a la publicación. Para mayor detalle:

Disciplinas de Investigación



WOS
Medicine, General & Internal
Scopus
Sin Disciplinas
SciELO
Sin Disciplinas

Muestra la distribución de disciplinas para esta publicación.

Publicaciones WoS (Ediciones: ISSHP, ISTP, AHCI, SSCI, SCI), Scopus, SciELO Chile.

Colaboración Institucional



Muestra la distribución de colaboración, tanto nacional como extranjera, generada en esta publicación.


Autores - Afiliación



Ord. Autor Género Institución - País
1 Gates, Michelle Mujer Univ Alberta - Canadá
2 Gates, Allison Mujer Univ Alberta - Canadá
3 Pieper, Dawid Hombre Witten Herdecke Univ - Alemania
4 Fernandes, Ricardo M. Hombre Univ Lisbon - Portugal
5 Tricco, Andrea C. Mujer St Michaels Hosp - Canadá
UNIV TORONTO - Canadá
Queens Univ - Canadá
6 Moher, D. Hombre Univ Ottawa - Canadá
7 Brennan, Sue E. Mujer MONASH UNIV - Australia
8 Li, Tianjing - UNIV COLORADO - Estados Unidos
9 Pollock, Michelle Mujer Inst Hlth Econ - Canadá
10 Lunny, Carole Mujer St Michaels Hosp - Canadá
11 VILLARROEL-VILLARROEL, LUIS Hombre Ministerio de Salud - Chile
Autonomous Univ Chile - Chile
12 McKenzie, Joanne E. Mujer MONASH UNIV - Australia
13 Scott, Shannon D. Mujer Univ Alberta - Canadá
14 Robinson, Karen A. Mujer Johns Hopkins Univ - Estados Unidos
15 Matthias, Katja Mujer Univ Appl Sci Stralsund - Alemania
16 Bougioukas, Konstantinos Hombre Aristotle Univ Thessaloniki - Grecia
17 Fusar-Poli, Paolo Hombre Kings Collect London - Reino Unido
South London & Maudsley NHS Fdn Trust - Reino Unido
Univ Pavia - Italia
18 Whiting, Penny Mujer Univ Bristol - Reino Unido
19 Moss, Stephana J. - Univ Calgary - Canadá
20 Hartling, Lisa Mujer Univ Alberta - Canadá

Muestra la afiliación y género (detectado) para los co-autores de la publicación.

Financiamiento



Fuente
Canadian Institutes of Health Research
Canada Research Chair
National Health and Medical Research Council Career Development Fellowship
CIHR Frederick Banting and Charles Best Canada doctoral scholarship
National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health

Muestra la fuente de financiamiento declarada en la publicación.

Agradecimientos



Agradecimiento
No specific funding was received for this project. ACT is funded by a tier 2 Canada Research Chair for knowledge synthesis. TL was funded by grant UG1EY020522 from the National Eye Institute, National Institutes of Health. CL is funded through a 2020 Canadian Institutes of Health Research project grant (2021-2024) . JEM is supported by a National Health and Medical Research Council career development fellowship (1143429) . SDS is supported by a Canada Research Chair for knowledge translation in child health. SJM was supported by the CIHR Frederick Banting and Charles Best Canada doctoral scholarship. LH is supported by a Canada Research Chair for knowledge synthesis and translation.

Muestra la fuente de financiamiento declarada en la publicación.