Muestra métricas de impacto externas asociadas a la publicación. Para mayor detalle:
| Indexado |
|
||||
| DOI | 10.3390/GEOSCIENCES10020061 | ||||
| Año | 2020 | ||||
| Tipo | material editorial |
Citas Totales
Autores Afiliación Chile
Instituciones Chile
% Participación
Internacional
Autores
Afiliación Extranjera
Instituciones
Extranjeras
A careful reading of Bonnail et al. (2019)'s work points out some issues in the description of the Ganges River, e.g., describing it in a way that gives impression to the readers unfamiliar with the Indian rivers that it flows by the national capital New Delhi, after reading "it receives inputs from highly populated cities of India, including New Delhi and horizontal ellipsis ". However, as a matter of fact, it is not the Ganges, but the Yamuna River, a tributary of the Ganges, that passes through the National Capital Region of Delhi. Moreover, authors identify the studied river as the Ganges, whereas it is one of the distributaries of the Ganges called Hooghly (anglicized version of its local name Hugli). They have referred to the seasonality of the studied river; however, the flow of the studied (Hooghly) river is controlled by a barrage on the Ganges River. Moreover, Hooghly River receives input from its own tributaries; viz., Mayurakshi and Damodar, flowing through highly mineralized and coaliferous areas of Jharkhand state of India. Bonnail et al. (2019) have attributed the contamination of the river sediments to anthropogenic activities alone, by not evaluating likely natural sources. A correction factor for the underestimated total organic carbon (TOC) content obtained using Walkley-Black method should have been applied before using TOC values for factor analysis to overcome the underestimation issue with this method. This work intends to serve as a compendium, rather than a critique, to otherwise commendable work by Bonnail et al. (2019).
| Ord. | Autor | Género | Institución - País |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Alam, Mohammad Ayaz | Hombre |
Universidad de Atacama - Chile
|
| Agradecimiento |
|---|
| Author thanks Universidad de Atacama for administrative and technical support to carry out this work. Author is grateful to the editorial handling by Ashley Zhang and three anonymous reviewers for their feedback, which has also motivated the author to plan a future project on the Ganges River to study some of the less studied aspects about this important river in the Indian Subcontinent. |